Blog
Home / Blog / CafePress vs Zazzle
Custom Team Apparel with No Minimums. Free Shipping. Launch Your Shop Free.

CafePress vs Zazzle: Comparing Two Marketplaces for Merch Sellers

June 17, 2026 6 min read By Cameron Wells
Quick Answer
Table of Contents
  1. CafePress and Zazzle side by side
  2. What actually differs between the two
  3. What neither platform gives an apparel-first seller
  4. A dedicated apparel-only alternative
  5. Frequently Asked Questions

CafePress and Zazzle are frequently compared because they run nearly the same underlying model: a broad personalization marketplace where a seller uploads a design to an existing product template, sets a markup on top of the platform's base price, and sells through a shop page hosted on the marketplace's own domain. The comparison a seller is usually really making is which marketplace has better shopper traffic and search visibility for their specific niche, not which structure works differently, since the structures are largely the same.

CafePress and Zazzle Side by Side

CategoryCafePressZazzle
StorefrontShop page on CafePress's marketplace domainShop page on Zazzle's marketplace domain
Catalog focusWide: apparel, mugs, stickers, home goods, giftsWide: apparel, invitations, stationery, drinkware, gifts
Pricing modelBase price plus seller markupBase price plus seller royalty
Order minimum1 piece1 piece
Shipping to buyerCalculated at checkoutCalculated at checkout
Monthly cost to sellFree to listFree to list

What Actually Differs Between the Two

Both platforms have been running for a long time and both cover a similarly broad set of products. In practice, the meaningful difference for most sellers is niche fit inside each marketplace's own search and browse traffic, and personal taste in design tools and templates, rather than any structural difference in how a shop is set up or how a seller gets paid. A seller weighing CafePress against Zazzle should treat it less like choosing a business model and more like choosing which storefront currently gets better visibility for their specific product idea.

Bear Grips Pro Shops: Custom Apparel for Your Team. No Minimums. Free Shipping.

What Neither Platform Gives an Apparel-First Seller

Because both CafePress and Zazzle mix apparel into a much wider catalog, neither is built specifically around an apparel business. A gym, studio, or creator selling primarily tees, hoodies, and hats is competing for visibility inside a marketplace where most of the catalog and most of the search traffic is not apparel at all. Neither platform gives that seller their own branded shop domain, a fixed shipping-included price, or a vendor referral program tied to bringing other apparel sellers onto the platform.

A Dedicated Apparel-Only Alternative

Bear Grips Pro Shops is built specifically around apparel and headwear rather than a general gift catalog: 63 products from Bella+Canvas, Next Level, Champion, Gildan, Sport-Tek, and other recognized brands, with tees from $19.88 VIP base and hoodies from $36.88. Every vendor gets a branded shop rather than a page on a shared marketplace domain, sets the full retail price and keeps the margin instead of a royalty or markup split, and gets free US shipping folded into the price. See the product lineup comparison for how the apparel specifically stacks up.

Skip the Shared Marketplace Catalog

An apparel-only branded shop, full retail price control, free shipping included. Free plan to start.

Start Free

Frequently Asked Questions

Is CafePress owned by Zazzle or the other way around?

No. They are separate, independently operated companies with no ownership relationship between them.

Does one of the two have lower fees for sellers?

Both are generally free to list and sell on, with earnings coming from the seller's own markup or royalty over the platform base price. Neither publishes a flat, all-in seller cost the way a fixed-price shop does.

Which is better for apparel specifically?

Neither is apparel-focused. Both mix apparel into a wider catalog of mugs, stationery, and gifts, so an apparel-first seller is one option among many product categories on either platform.

Is Bear Grips Pro Shops a combination of CafePress and Zazzle?

No. Bear Grips Pro Shops is an independent apparel platform with its own catalog, pricing, and print process, unrelated to either company.

Cameron Wells
Cameron WellsCustom Apparel and POD Industry Writer

Cameron has been writing about the custom apparel and print on demand industry for seven years, with a background in e-commerce operations. He covers platform comparisons, no-minimum vendors, and what is changing for small custom merch businesses.

More articles by Cameron →
Bear Grips Pro Shops: Free storefronts for gyms, clubs, and teams. No inventory. No risk.