Elementary School Spirit Shirt Design Contest: A Step-by-Step Playbook

The spirit shirt design contest is the single highest-leverage thing a PTA can do for shirt sales. Every kid in the school who submits a drawing tells their parents about it, every family votes, and every family that votes orders the winning shirt. A well-run contest can triple spirit-shirt revenue over the no-contest version. Here is the playbook: rules, judging, theme prompts, and how to convert the winning kid's drawing into a real shirt.

Why a Design Contest Triples Spirit-Shirt Sales

Three mechanics drive the lift:

• Every submitting family is now invested. A kid who drew a logo wants to see their drawing on a real shirt, and the parents will buy two.
• Voting families pre-commit. Asking a family to vote on three designs makes them 40 percent more likely to order the winning shirt later.
• Social proof of the winning kid. The winner becomes a school celebrity for a week. Every classmate's parent wants to support by buying one.

The compounding effect: a 400-family elementary school that typically sells 80 of one spirit-shirt design will sell 200 to 250 of the contest-winning design. The shirt becomes "the shirt Sam drew," not just "the school shirt."

Contest Rules: Keep Them Simple, Make Them Fair

The rules document needs five sections, no more:

1. Theme. One sentence. "Design a shirt that shows what makes our school special."
2. Age brackets. K-2 and 3-5 are judged separately. The K-2 winners go through a special "kindergarten artist" lane so a 2nd grader does not lose to a 5th grader on technical merit.
3. Format. One sheet of paper, school-color crayons or markers, the kid's name and grade on the back. Digital submissions optional for 4th-5th.
4. Deadline. Three weeks from announcement. Submitting late = not eligible.
5. Prize. The winning design becomes the school's spirit shirt for the year. The winning kid gets the first printed shirt, an embroidered hat with their initials, and recognition at the school assembly.

What does NOT go in the rules: complex copyright language, multiple submission limits, complicated judging rubrics. The simpler the rules, the more submissions.

Bear Grips Pro Shops: Custom Apparel for Your Team. No Minimums. Free Shipping.

Theme Prompts That Drive the Most Submissions

The theme prompt is the most important variable. Prompts that generate 100+ submissions at a 400-family school:

• "Show what makes our school special." The default, works at any school.
• "Draw our mascot doing what you love." Works because every kid gets to insert themselves.
• "What does [school name] mean to you?" Heartstring prompt for older kids.
• "Design the shirt for spirit week 2026." Time-limited, drives urgency.
• "Our mascot in [city or town name]." Local-pride prompt, especially good for small towns.

Avoid prompts that limit imagination. "Draw a circle with our school name" is technically a design contest but generates 12 entries.

Judging the Submissions and Picking a Winner

Two-step judging process:

1. Internal jury picks the top 6. PTA officers, art teacher, principal each pick their top 3. Combined list, deduplicate, top 6 by votes.
2. School-wide vote on the top 6. Digital voting via the PTA website or printed ballots in the Friday folder. Families vote with their student. One vote per family.

Announce the winner at a school assembly. Hand the winner the first printed shirt on stage. Take a photo. Share the photo in the next PTA email blast with the shop link. The conversion rate on that email is 30 to 40 percent of recipients.

The honesty rule: the jury must include the art teacher specifically to keep the top-6 list focused on designs that will translate to print. The art teacher knows which crayon drawings will look amazing as a screen print and which ones will not.

Converting the Winning Drawing to a Print-Ready Design

The hardest part is making the kid's drawing print well without losing the original feel. The four-step conversion:

1. Scan the original at 600 DPI. A high-resolution scan preserves the line work that makes a kid's drawing feel like a kid's drawing.
2. Trace the line work in Illustrator (or hire it out for $25-$50). The crayon strokes get traced as a single-color vector that prints cleanly.
3. Keep imperfections. Wonky lines, asymmetric eyes, the way kids draw a star. These are the design. Smoothing them ruins it.
4. Color-match to a single school color. Most kid designs work best printed in a single school color (white ink on a colored tee, or school color ink on a white tee).

The whole conversion takes a graphic designer 30 to 60 minutes. The PTA pays $30 to $75 for the work and ends up with a print-ready file. For the production side, see our PTA apparel program guide.

Frequently Asked Questions

How many submissions does a typical elementary school design contest get?

50 to 150 submissions at a 400-family school, depending on the theme and how prominently the contest is promoted. Strong promotion (Friday folder + email + assembly announcement) drives the higher end.

Who owns the winning design once it is on a shirt?

The school owns the right to use the design on PTA-produced apparel. The kid (and the kid's family) keep the original artwork. This should be stated in the rules document.

Should we run the contest every year or every few years?

Every year, with a different theme. Annual contests build culture. The kid who lost in 2nd grade will submit again in 3rd, and the school becomes one where everyone has submitted at least once.

How long does the whole contest take from announcement to printed shirts?

About 8 weeks. Three weeks of submission, one week of judging and voting, one week of conversion to print-ready, three weeks of orders plus printing.